Testimonials

I have known Brenda Donnelly since 2019, and her impact on our real estate ventures has been nothing short of extraordinary. When other realtors dismissed us, Brenda took us seriously and helped us navigate the competitive market to secure our dream home in Old Town, Key West. Since then, we have purchased five additional properties with her expert guidance.

Brenda also manages two of our rental properties, and her no-nonsense approach ensures that they are maintained to the highest standards. She has an uncanny ability to work tirelessly, always prioritizing her clients' best interests. Her honesty and trustworthiness are unparalleled, making her a reliable partner in the real estate market.

Her incredible support team further enhances her service, contributing to her reputation as an award-winning realtor in Key West. Brenda’s relentless work ethic and commitment to excellence truly set her apart. If you’re looking for a realtor who will go above and beyond, Brenda Donnelly is the one to choose. She works like a crazed weasel, ensuring every detail is perfect and every transaction is smooth. Highly recommended!

We recently sold two properties and bought one. Brenda represented us in all three transactions. She gave us great support and advice both when selling and buying. All of the transactions closed flawlessly, in large part due to Brenda’s expertise and professionalism.

Without Brenda Donnelly, our dream of owning a home in Key West would likely never have become reality. We first met Brenda through her vacation rental business. We had been visiting the island for years, experiencing various levels of vacation rental quality through various agencies. Once we booked through Historic Key West Vacation Rentals, we never booked with another agency again. Their rental homes are all top notch, and their service team extremely responsive. Of course, seeing how nice life on the island could be while ensconced in a luxury rental, we had to make the switch to permanent residency. For such a small island, there’s so much to know before buying. Throughout all of our visits, I’ve never met anyone with more knowledge of the local real estate market than Brenda. Her grasp of the various community “personalities”, the rich history of every street and each home is unmatched. Even Brenda’s knowledge of the topography was so helpful to us in finding the perfect home. I’m sure we drove her crazy, wanting to see so many houses, but she made the process so enjoyable and taught us so much about our adopted city. We are so happy with the home we purchased and can’t thank her enough for matching us with our dream house.

We were fortunate to meet Brenda Donnelly 11 year ago at an open house. She was immediately receptive to our needs and wants in obtaining a home in Key West. We had flown in for a long weekend and our realtor that we had appointments with stood us up and was unable to show us any properties. Brenda stepped in and not only showed us homes but gave us a crash course in island living pros and cons. We didn't buy that weekend but we continued searching together for our dream home. Within the month Brenda found us the perfect property and the rest is history. We have watched her grow in her career obtaining her brokers license and always keeping up to date on all the trends that impact real estate. We have since bought other properties with her and are always amazed at her diligence, knowledge base and attention to detail. She is a trusted realtor, broker and friend that we highly recommend.

Brenda Donnelly knows Key West!

First, she listened to our list of ‘wants’. Based on that, she drove us all over Key West and recommended neighborhoods.
Our first home was such a great experience that we trusted her again when we were ready for a larger home.
Brenda found us a beautiful home in a neighborhood that is perfectly suited for us!

We have worked with Brenda Donnelly on many occasions. She is extremely professional and hard working with a wealth of knowledge. She has bought us many buyers in the past few years and in our opinion is the most professional real estate agent we have worked with. We look forward to working with Brenda in the future.